Thread: Truly Crappy Bay Rums

Originally Posted by JMS

I use Dominica with and without lime exclusively And I must say that it is the purdyist smellin' horse piss this side of the Mississippi!

Hmm, I like the Capt Smith but maybe I'll have to try the Dominica. Just noticed you are almost my neighbor, I am in Oceanside and go to Ramona on occasion to chase some cows with my horse.

Mike

I want to chime in here .... I LOVE Bay Rum, I have a decent collection of them now. Among my everyday rotation I have Ogalalla,
Dominica, Captain Smith, and a bottle I got from a place call the
Old Village Barber Shop (I think they are in N.H.). The O.V.B.S has a Bay Rum deodorant that i LOVE!!!

But back to the subject at hand...

I think that the brand "Masters" Bay Rum is the most VILE smell I have ever tried ... I think it is from the same stream as the products you have described.

I know Masters has a following... but I don't understand why.

Just my 2 cents.....

Steve

Keep in mind when you go into one of those fru-fru expensive botiques and buy some imported or other after shave or cologne for the big bucks the stuff is made of alcohol, water and fragrance just like the cheap stuff just that it smells better to some.

By the way I think Dominica bay Rum smells great and anyone who dares knock old spice deserves to be executed.

I love Bay Rum. I like the post that there are crisp Island versions and clovey versions = I hadn't been able to articulate that in my own mind. Of those I've tried

1. Domenica - love it. [island]
2. Pinaud - love it. [island]
3. Ogallalah - love the old clovey version, new spicier version is ok, I have mixed feelings about the BR/Sandlewood and BR/LemonPeppercor
4. HoneyBeeGardens [clovey] - love it - it's slid under the radar

Old Spice Rocks.

Originally Posted by loueedacat

I love Bay Rum. I like the post that there are crisp Island versions and clovey versions = I hadn't been able to articulate that in my own mind. Of those I've tried

1. Domenica - love it. [island]
2. Pinaud - love it. [island]
3. Ogallalah - love the old clovey version, new spicier version is ok, I have mixed feelings about the BR/Sandlewood and BR/LemonPeppercor
4. HoneyBeeGardens [clovey] - love it - it's slid under the radar

Old Spice Rocks.

Hey great but this isn't about what bay rums you love. This thread is about the bay rums that suck, like Master's or the Dominica with lime.

Originally Posted by megabit

Hmm, I like the Capt Smith but maybe I'll have to try the Dominica. Just noticed you are almost my neighbor, I am in Oceanside and go to Ramona on occasion to chase some cows with my horse.

Mike

Next time you're coming up my way just PM me and maybe we could meet up!?