Among the many post shave balms, witch hazel, Alum, etc...You can try Nivea's Post shave balm in a black tube. It's amazingly good. I picked some up the other day in Wal Greens. Now, I'm addicted to Truefitt's and Hills 1805 post shave balm. The fragrance is great, but it's expensive, so I'm frugal with it...So that's where the Nivea comes in...
It's good stuff and about 5 or 6 bucks if I'm not mistaken...A great deal, and it will sooth your skin....+1