I also really like Skin Food (both types) and witch hazel. I've never had either one sting even when applied directly over a cut.

Before passing final judgement on the Classic Balm, try applying it to a small section of your neck (unshaved portion) or forearm. This should tell you if you are particularly sensitive to the product vs. it stinging due to razor burn. I should mention that I have heard of several individuals that cannot use this particular product because of reactions to it.

Ed