Thread: So much info - Searching SRP efficiently

Yea, searching can be difficult and frustrating at times on this site. I don’t know how the search criteria is set up, but I suspect that much of the problem is that information is buried in a totally unrelated titled thread.

And even when you know the title of a thread, the advanced search will not find it. For example, I often refer folks to a thread, “Second Try at Honing-Seeking Opinions” if you search those words the advanced search will not retrieve it.

1. This is the response I get. “The following words are either very common, too long, or too short and were not included in your search:
"second-try-honing-seeking-opinions"

Yet, searching those same words on Google, the thread pops up, first hit.

Pretty much everything you need to know is here: https://shavelibrary.com/w/Shave_Library

The way I see it is, questions, even repeated questions are good as it keeps the Palace alive. If everyone only used the search button it would be a very boring forum indeed.

Originally Posted by markbignosekelly

Pretty much everything you need to know is here: https://shavelibrary.com/w/Shave_Library

The way I see it is, questions, even repeated questions are good as it keeps the Palace alive. If everyone only used the search button it would be a very boring forum indeed.

the only problem is space required to repeatedly answer with same response to different new members

A real benefit of SRP lies in the connections to be made among members.

The connections often start with a question or a request for and offering of advice. Rhere is great value in that aspect of the forum.

There is a significant collective memory here that gets preserved in the archived threads and posts. I don’t think making it easier to access that incredible database of information and experience will reduce the other relationship building that occurs among the members. It might even reduce the frustration some senior members feel when confronted with the same questions they’ve answered many times before.

The search function works great on my laptop but not very well on my iPad.
Also sometimes if you look first, you can get the question refined first so you are asking about specific things and not vague things. No one wants to try to answer how long is a piece of string, but get the question to more specific parameters. . .

Ask the question

If it is well covered you will get the links that we think to answer it best
If it is an evolving idea your question could get many answers and start a good discussion on it

Being perfectly honest the only question I don't like seeing is "What is the Best......." I try and stay out of those

We have two searches. The first is the one built in the software and is available in the 'advanced search' button. I think it's a simple query of the database for the search terms and the only ranking on the results is by date.

The other search is that toolbar with the magnifying glass and that's google's search of our site. They index all of our content and then use machine learning algorithms to rank the results by 'relevance'.

But at the end of the day we're a community and nothing can compare to actual people
This is the real wealth of our forum!

The title of a thread is key IMO. When someone wants to ask a question about a subject like Shave Angle then titles his thread "just wanting to know..." It doesnt help anyone when trying the search.

Searching is good and ive done it a lot, but what i get back from the search is way too much or not what im looking for. Sometimes i get lucky.

Would it be a good idea to offer a tutorial on how to create a search using the various options available in the advanced search function? There are drop down menus that narrow the scope of a search and folks can use AND, OR and - (NOT) to filter the results.

forum
[fawr-uh m, fohr-uh m]
noun, plural fo·rums, fo·ra [fawr-uh, fohr-uh] /ˈfɔr ə, ˈfoʊr ə/.
1. the marketplace or public square of an ancient Roman city, the center of judicial and business affairs and aplace of assembly for the people.


I never understood the guys who barked the “look it up” mantra.

If you don’t want to answer the guys question, let someone else do it. Yes, there is tons of information buried in the forum, but knowing where to start digging, can be a problem. It is a Public Place, engage or not.

Fortunately, most of those guys are gone now, rarely is there a post or question that goes unanswered, and even responses to pedestrian questions are filled with good information.

I try to think of the hundreds of other guys who will read a post, wanting the same information and never asking.

Yes, the search is somewhat lacking, but Google will often find the answer and link it right back to the forum. Why is that?