It seems that we are coming back around to the idea of "Shave Tested" either in addition to or in lieu of "Shave Ready."

Did the seller use the razor to complete a comfortable shave or not? Everyone seems to agree that the only test for sharpness is the shave test, so why not have this be the standard by which a razor's sharpness is judged on razors for sale?

Can we all agree, that if a seller does in fact complete a comfortable shave with said razor, that the razor is, at least at some level, "shave ready?" Sure, it might not be the sharpest it could be, and maybe not up to some member's standards, but if it can comfortably shave one guy's face, I would think it should be sharp enough to shave most guy's faces.