I voted yes as i have no problem suppurating the site. Issues i would have is with "special forums and content for paying subscribers" the forum would likely suffer if there were locked rooms that you needed to pay to enter... quite likely there would be less interaction between the subscribers and say the newbie with the 105 questions we have all answered a 1000 times. they might just get lost and never learn the proper joy of a straight razor shave.

To an extent that happens now when instead of giving people an answer we refer them to the wiki.

Badges... we don't need no stinking badges! it should be enough to know that you have a vested interest in the site without it needing to be highlighted for others to see.

blogs... they are for people who should be out looking for work!

another email address.. was this not tried several years ago and found to be underused?

more photo space... believe it or not there are still photo-hosting sites.

keeping SRP a friendly place where people can ask pretty much any question and receive a timely answer or even three mutually exclusive different answers. is a good thing.

so the next thing is what do you plan on doing when you need to ban a paying member?