Quote Originally Posted by loueedacat View Post
I think it looks good. I might split out creams from soaps.

Also, I've never thought the numerical ratings add any value whatsoever. We might have the same experience, and I"d give it a 7 and you'd say 10, and who knows what either means. And on other sites the numberical ratings tend to be too high or too low (becasue we all love a product or don't). Just my two cents, but I'd get rid of the numerical ratings but encourage [but not require] textual analysis of those categories.
I completely agree. The numbers really mean nothing - and we'll know from the text whether the author really likes a product, sort of likes a product, or doesn't like a product. I prefer it when our forum doesn't look the same as all the others.

Jordan