Quote Originally Posted by thebigspendur View Post
Quite honestly I don't see the connection between soap and aftershave. To me no matter what the scent is or how strong it is once the soap comes off there should be no scent left on your skin. To me that would be a huge defect in the soap and actually no soap I have ever used did linger. Now if your talking say moisturizing qualities of the soap paired with the same in an aftershave that's a different story.

If you want to discuss the two in a review I don't see any problem with that but I wouldn't be making any official rating criteria here. Most guys don't use the simple ones we have now.
Wow, I must either have a sensitive nose or skin that absorbs scents more than other gents. I have used several soaps that once rinsed off leave a lingering scent for some time. TOBS Shaving Shop and a few of the TGQ soaps (vanilla sandalwood and orange patchouli come to mind). Is my experience an anomaly?

Chris L