Long before I ever picked up a straight razor, I used the Mach type razors. I also used a mug of Williams soap and a boar brush reliqously. I face lathered, and had no trouble. I don't know of Dirty Deeds Beer soap, maybe someone does, and will chime in, but if you lather right from the puck to your face, I.E. Put it in a mug, wet it, and the brush, shake out excess, and whip away, you should get some lather. To answer your question, Yes, Creams tend to provide more lather. Also, Target and Wal Mart super center's usually have Van Der Hagen soap. A lot of the member's rave about it. Give it a try.