Go for the Williams. I have used it for over 40 years and have found it to be a good soap. There are better and there are worse with Marvy being near the bottom of the list.

I have never had any trouble lathering with Williams though it does need a little more water than others. I think if it were $7.00 instead of $.97 at the local grocery, it would get a higher rating.

Just my opinion.

Will N.