Thread: Top 5 Shaving Soaps

I've tried dozens. My thoughts:

If I were starting over, I'd get a kilo of Cella, a small bowl, scoop and replace as necessary, and want for nothing. Cheap, easy, luscious.

MWF. Sublime when it's right, but it IS finicky. Never the same suds twice.

Pre de Provence. I feel like a 17th century fop whenever I use it. (Good thing, BTW). Reliable.

Trumper's. Simple and effective. Traditionalist English vibe must represent on any top 5 list, right?

Speick. Why do I still have to grate the sticks? They need to make a bowled soap or puck. Great stuff, maybe the best scent in the business.

Ok. ill play.

Martin de candre
DR Harris Arlington
Pre de.provence
Mikes orange
Mwf

1. Tabac / Irisch Moos
2. Mitchell's Wool Fat
3. Martin de Candre scented
4. D.R. Harris Arlington
5. Calani Gentlemen

Ben

1. Stirling Anise
2. Harris Marlborough
3. MWF
4. Speick
5. Stirling Coniferous

Amazing lists folks, I have my own...

Mitchell's Wool Fat
Vintage Yardley
Queen Charlotte

This is my top 3, but MWF is for sure my top option... After I read more about him on internet I decite to try it and after then for me there is only one choice!

1) MWF. 2) Tabac. 3) SRD. 4) MWF. 5) Tabac.

1. P160 happy to say I have a stash.
2. MDC
3. XPEC

Others are so far removed I have to cut the list at 3.

1. Mitchell's Wool Fat

2. Klar Kabinett .. now unfortunately, gone!

3. Re-milled Palmolive Shave Stick

4. D.R. Harris Arlington

5. Williams Mug Soap

1. MDC Fougere

2. MWF

3. DR Harris Windsor

4. Savon Babre Osma

5. Tabac

6. Proraso Red, Blue and White are always worth a mention in my books...they're like a good friend, always there and never disappoint!

I gonna assume that cremes would be allowed on this list to.

1. The Art of Shaving Sandalwood Shave Creme
2. Proraso(either green or red)
3.Tabac
4.Stirling Soap Company (Almond Creme)
5.The Holy Black (gunpowder spice)