Thread: smooth vs sharp - how to

I think a better "verbage" for your question might be 'smooth' vs. 'keen'.

I have seen it described, but it doesn't really do it justice. The best way to see the difference is to hone a blade to 8k, then shave. Afterwards, do a few laps on the 12k. The 8k will be more "comfortable".

"buttery" is basically comparing your shave to cutting butter with a hot knife. No resistance and little sensation of the blade on the face. This is far buried in the "YMMV" area, depending on coarseness of hair and the sensitivity of your skin. Having good lather will also make the world of difference.

I would recommend against a 16k if you are looking for a smoother, more comfortable edge. Particularly when starting out in honing. 16k is not a cheap finisher and 12k will probably satisfy your balance of "keen" and "smooth".