Thread: NaJorton has got me thinking about overhoning with higher grit hones

Originally Posted by Str8Shooter

Well I had been thinking I had been overhoning certain blades (full hollow) I still think that may be the case..
Paul

You also have to consider whether it is more likely that you will overhone on the finter grit hones or underhone. I think it much more likely that you will underhone. I think it much more likely that you will sabotage your honing from worry about overhoning by then underhoning. But, the proof is in the edge. If you come to the end of your honing, and the edge is not sharp, well then back to the drawing boards.

Originally Posted by LarryAndro

You also have to consider whether it is more likely that you will overhone on the finter grit hones or underhone. I think it much more likely that you will underhone. I think it much more likely that you will sabotage your honing from worry about overhoning by then underhoning. But, the proof is in the edge. If you come to the end of your honing, and the edge is not sharp, well then back to the drawing boards.

Clearly. My whole poiint of this is that a few of my edge's are slightly harsh. Still crazy sharp and under magnification highly polished. I think they might have developed a wire edge that is breaking.

Originally Posted by Str8Shooter

Clearly. My whole poiint of this is that a few of my edge's are slightly harsh. Still crazy sharp and under magnification highly polished. I think they might have developed a wire edge that is breaking.

If the edges are very sharp and highly polished, and you have stropped them sufficiently, and probably used something like chromium oxide or diamond before the leather stropping, then you have to consider the possibility that the harshness is not due to burrs or wire edges or overhoning. Even though I am afraid this will kick off another round of gnashing of teeth by some here, you might just have a very sharp edge. And, if you strop a few times, and the shaves become comfortable, it might be because the edge has lost just a little of the V shaped sharpness and is now more of a very, very sharp U shape. Still very sharp, but, due to the slight rounding of the bevel immediately before the cutting edge, gentler on my skin.

Originally Posted by LarryAndro

If the edges are very sharp and highly polished, and you have stropped them sufficiently, and probably used something like chromium oxide or diamond before the leather stropping, then you have to consider the possibility that the harshness is not due to burrs or wire edges or overhoning. Even though I am afraid this will kick off another round of gnashing of teeth by some here, you might just have a very sharp edge. And, if you strop a few times, and the shaves become comfortable, it might be because the edge has lost just a little of the V shaped sharpness and is now more of a very, very sharp U shape. Still very sharp, but, due to the slight rounding of the bevel immediately before the cutting edge, gentler on my skin.

Good point Larry

I'm loving all the different answers and opinions in this thread....I've been reading it daily rubbing my chin and thinking "hmmm, I like that....oh wait...I like that too....".