Page 1 of 10 12345 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 92
Like Tree57Likes

Thread: Straight razor sharpening and my Edge Pro - Pic intensive

  1. #1
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default Straight razor sharpening and my Edge Pro - Pic intensive

    Wasn't sure what forum to put this in. Hopefully this is the correct one.

    Just a brief reader’s digest history... I have been collecting knives and sharpening them with an Edge Pro Apex for a while (120 grit - 6k grit). I have read the Edge Pro posts on this site and in no way do I want to start a "flame war". I wanted to see if I could use the Edge Pro because I have invested time in money in this system with my knives.

    First off, I am very new to wet shaving and using a straight razor. I started using a Parker SR1 and could not resist the urge to buy a real straight razor. After visiting a local antique shop (and reading the beginners wiki) page I bought 2 razors: Bingham Quality and Giensen Forsthoff razor. I could have bought another 2 razors but I decided to stop myself.

    Name:  20130420_140102.jpg
Views: 2917
Size:  25.5 KB

    Name:  20130420_141555.jpg
Views: 3160
Size:  19.2 KB

    Name:  20130420_141603.jpg
Views: 2817
Size:  20.5 KB

    Name:  20130420_141629.jpg
Views: 2852
Size:  21.3 KB

    Name:  20130420_141639.jpg
Views: 2835
Size:  20.5 KB

    Name:  20130420_144125.jpg
Views: 2849
Size:  22.5 KB

    Name:  20130420_144130.jpg
Views: 2800
Size:  22.9 KB

    Name:  20130420_144137.jpg
Views: 2785
Size:  18.5 KB

    Name:  20130420_144205.jpg
Views: 2877
Size:  19.3 KB

    After looking at the edges with a 10x eye loupe I deemed them serviceable. By serviceable, I did not see any chipping or damage. I ran the blade on my thumbnail to check to any edge issues as well as running a cotton ball perpendicular to the edge to feel for issues on the edges. I started cleaning the Giesen Forsthoff with some polishing paste and a rag and some brasso. This was a first pass cleaning as I do not currently have any wet sanding paper.

    Here is my EP setup.

    Name:  20130421_102741.jpg
Views: 2916
Size:  68.9 KB

    To be cont...

  2. #2
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default

    EP table setup

    Understanding that the razor is a very thin edge blade, I thought about how to set the EP up so that the razor did not get bent/distorted and came up with the plastic card shim. The shim allows for a small section of the blade to hang off the EP platform. The second card is to provide a stop for the razor's edge so it can be placed on the EP consistently.

    Name:  20130421_101302.jpg
Views: 2815
Size:  36.5 KB

    Name:  20130421_101308.jpg
Views: 2813
Size:  37.5 KB

    Name:  20130421_101435.jpg
Views: 4494
Size:  27.1 KB

    EP arm setup

    Ben Dale from Edge Pro suggested I keep the EP arm as close to the cutting edge of the razor as well as the spine without touching the spine. From the videos I have watched, the spine acts as a guide when drawing the razor across a strop or stone. To remedy this, I placed some painters tape on the spine of the razor and then placed the arm in a position where the cutting edge and the spine were in contact.

    Name:  20130421_101521.jpg
Views: 3621
Size:  27.8 KB

    After the arm was set I removed the tape and went to the sharpening. As previously mentioned in other posts, I use the sharpie method. I cover the cutting edge with sharpie and then slide the stone/polish tape over the edge to see if the media is cutting the edge properly.

    Name:  20130420_155145.jpg
Views: 2856
Size:  33.8 KB

    Name:  20130420_155237.jpg
Views: 2825
Size:  28.0 KB

    I verified that the spine was not getting touched by the tape by marking the spine and cutting edge again with sharpie.

    Name:  20130421_105454.jpg
Views: 2766
Size:  40.9 KB

    Sharpening procedure

    I first thougt of starting at my 1k stone but decided to start using my 2k polishing tape. I first tested the razor with the arm shave test to see how it performed. The blade was sharp but did not shave. Now the fun begins...

    I sectioned the blade in two when I started drawing the tape over the edge. From the point to the middle of the blade and from the shoulder to the middle of the blade. After that I would pas the tape over the middle section. The tape would be lubricated with a water and dish soap mix between passes.

    Here are the tape progressions Pass pattern 20, 15, 10, 5:

    2k tape: 20 passes (front to back stroke = 1 stroke) - point to middle
    20 passes - shoulder to middle
    20 passes -middle area
    Flip razor and repeat

    15 passes - point to midle
    15 passes - shoulder to middle
    15 passes - middle area
    Flip razor and repeat

    All the way down to 5 passes.
    3k tape: Same as above
    6k tape: Stopped at 20 passes.

    I stopped at 20 because I had to run some errands and I had to test the blade on my face.

    All that I did for face prep was a splash of water and some Target shaving gel that I had left over (no time to make lather as I was running late). I wiped the blade down with some isobroply alcohol and shaved my cheek. I was very happy with the results. The blade cut smoothly and easily. I do need to make a point about what my interpretation of smooth is. My sample size of straight razor shaves is all of 6. I have been using a shavette with Shark blades. So the experience I have may be on the lower end of the shave scale due to my initial setup. I am going to run the 6k tape through the full progression before I shave with it again.

    I also plan on buying wet sanding paper to clean up the blade itself.. As for a strop, I am not sure as of yet, not enough data against or for the EP...yet.

    *Update*

    I finished the blade with the 6k tape progression. Now to shave with it…

    Name:  20130421_120049.jpg
Views: 2730
Size:  14.9 KB

  3. #3
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default

    *Update*

    After shaving with this razor, I was amazed how differently a real straight razor feels vs. a shavette. I enjoyed hearing the blade cut the whiskers. It was very satisfying. And yes, I did cut myself 3 times. The cutting surface on this razor is almost 3 times longer than the Parker SR1 I started with. Time to buy a pencil.

    Mario-

  4. #4
    Senior Member blabbermouth JimmyHAD's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Posts
    32,564
    Thanked: 11042

    Default

    Moving this to the honing forum. Don't know if it is my eyes, the lighting in the photos, or what but ...... looks to me like a slight frown in that blade. Might have to do with the method ? Anyway, good luck with it.
    Last edited by JimmyHAD; 04-23-2013 at 04:08 AM.

  5. #5
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by JimmyHAD View Post
    ...... looks to me like a slight frown in that blade. Might have to do with the method ? Anyway, good luck with it.
    Thanks for pointing out the frown. I looked at the blade and then put it against the the counter top and sure enough there ws a small frown. I did a newb move when I got the razor. I did not check the geometry of the blade and went straight to sharpening.

    m-

  6. #6
    aka shooter74743 ScottGoodman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    SE Oklahoma/NE Texas
    Posts
    7,285
    Thanked: 1936
    Blog Entries
    4

    Default

    Mario,
    It sounds like you are good at sharpening knives, but I have to say razors different.

    I like your set-up by the way, I've been entertaining a set-up like that for my knives!

    You say your razor shaves well, but what is your experience? Please understand that I am not trying to discourage at all, but you need to have a veteran shaver shave with that razor and ask their opinion or have a razor around that was honed by a veteran honer to compare to. I would hate to see you get frustrated with our sport before you really got off the ground.
    Redcane likes this.
    Southeastern Oklahoma/Northeastern Texas helper. Please don't hesitate to contact me.
    Thank you and God Bless, Scott

  7. #7
    At this point in time... gssixgun's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    North Idaho Redoubt
    Posts
    26,948
    Thanked: 13221
    Blog Entries
    1

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Mario View Post
    Thanks for pointing out the frown. I looked at the blade and then put it against the the counter top and sure enough there ws a small frown. I did a newb move when I got the razor. I did not check the geometry of the blade and went straight to sharpening.

    m-

    Look up at the before pics,,,,

    Read Shooters post again, he is trying to help you out..

    There is a You tube video of IIRC the guy that invented the EP or one of those types using it for a Straight Razor, it looked as though he had a fairly smooth rhythm going sharpening both sides at the same time..
    Siguy and Redcane like this.

  8. #8
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by shooter74743 View Post
    Mario,
    It sounds like you are good at sharpening knives, but I have to say razors different.

    I like your set-up by the way, I've been entertaining a set-up like that for my knives!

    You say your razor shaves well, but what is your experience? Please understand that I am not trying to discourage at all, but you need to have a veteran shaver shave with that razor and ask their opinion or have a razor around that was honed by a veteran honer to compare to. I would hate to see you get frustrated with our sport before you really got off the ground.
    Thanks for the input. I understand whole heartily that I am a n00b in this new adventure. When I first started sharpening knives, the learning curve did not stop me from moving on and enjoying that hobby. So my experience with straight razors is getting close to 10 whole shaves. With that being said, I have really no experience. Compared to the shavette that I started with (Parker SR1), these razors feel smoother. However, I am probably comparing not "very good" with still "not very good" shaves. I intend to get a razor from Whipped Dog Straight Razor Shaving Equipment first and shave with it. Then I should have a good comparison. I also want to buy a stop but require more reading on this site for a good starting point. I will put my razors to the strop and see what that does as well. There is a fantastic thread with microscopic images of a .3 micron honing and a .3 micron honing + stropping which is truly fascinating. The softening of the scratches is truly remarkable.

    @ gssixgun-

    I looked at the pics I posted and then went through my album. Here is the blade before my n00b move:

    Name:  20130420_144130.jpg
Views: 2608
Size:  21.2 KB

    Had I been more patient and not jumped the gun, I should have seen the frown then. The sharpening system you are referring to is called the Wicked Edge. I have read up on it, but at the time it was just too expensive for me.

    Thanks again for the info.

    Mario-

  9. #9
    There is no charge for Awesomeness Jimbo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    Maleny, Australia
    Posts
    7,977
    Thanked: 1587
    Blog Entries
    3

    Default

    I guess there are many paths that we can take to get where we need to be, and honing is no different. We've developed a set of methods here that work for us, but that is not to say they are the only way to skin that cat.

    I have no experience with this EP setup at all, so really cannot comment on what it does or does not do. However my only comment on it is I personally think 6K maybe just a bit on the coarse side for my tastes. If all went well on the EP system up to that point I'd probably consider moving onto something of higher grit.

    I guess the other thing is that it may be a little limiting on razors that require a "rolling" stroke using traditional honing methods - the smiley sheffields for example. But I can see how this would be a perfectly acceptable method for perfect geometry blades if you knew what you were doing with it.

    James.
    <This signature intentionally left blank>

  10. The Following User Says Thank You to Jimbo For This Useful Post:

    Johnus (04-25-2013)

  11. #10
    Straight razor padawan
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Norcal.
    Posts
    52
    Thanked: 12

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Jimbo View Post
    I have no experience with this EP setup at all, so really cannot comment on what it does or does not do. However my only comment on it is I personally think 6K maybe just a bit on the coarse side for my tastes. If all went well on the EP system up to that point I'd probably consider moving onto something of higher grit.
    Jimbo-

    The polishing tape names are not really the true grit in terms of stones. That was a confusing part for me when I got into the EP system. The breakdown is as follows:

    2k tape = This tape is the same as a 20,000 grit Japanese water stone or 9 micron. *Taken from EP's website
    3k tape = This tape is the same as a 25,000 grit Japanese water stone or 3 micron. *Taken from EP's website
    6k tape = This tape is the same as a 30,000 grit Japanese water stone, or 1 micron. *Taken from EP's website

    After looking at Whippeddog's site, there is a lot of goodies for the n00b.

    m-

Page 1 of 10 12345 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •