Thread: Truly Crappy Bay Rums

Originally Posted by gssixgun

Scent is a personal thing so I couldn't help ya there, if you like the Bay Rum scent in general and you are looking for a longer lasting one I would recommend the Capt. Smith's, Ogalalla, or the Clubman brands...
These will never last as long as say Drakkar or any other cologne, just because they are AS's not cologne's...
They are basically 2 types of bay rums to my nose
The Island style which most fall into this category, and the what I call the Cowboy or Western style....
the Island style is a crisp clean scent like Dominica, Royall, Pusser's etc:
The Western is a heavier more clove scent like the Ogalalla
Personally I haven,t met a Bay Rum I don't like, but thats just me, there are some I like better than others....but to tell you what my nose likes does no good whatsoever.
The Royall is the standard in my eyes, probably because I remember buying that stuff for my pops for at least the last 45 years, that and Old spice were his AS of choice....

Hey Glen, I'm glad you chimed in. It was your thread that started my collecting of Bay Rums. Sadly it seems a large percentage of the ones I've collected are crappy. I thought I would start a thread with a humorous flavor regarding my poor selections. Fortunately these things are generally inexpensive so an obscure label on a bottle of equine urine may only cost $5. Be that as it may, it still piss. The defensive attitude of some folks regarding a cheap blend of alcohol, water and fragrance is amusing. I never thought that by bad mouthing Dominica I'd be treading on thin ice. Sure they mostly smell nice but why can't these scents last longer? Why aren't there Bay Rum colognes? Why aren't there cologne.after shave combination fluids?

I have to return to the original thread to make a list of the "better" Bay Rums and begin a search in earnest for those better blends and eschew the crappy ones. Of course we are all individuals and our personal preferences will vary. However, I'm with you on the Royall. That stuff seems to be different, maybe because it was so expensive I want it to be better. Maybe the leaf in the bottle has me fooled. Any way, I like how it feels and it seems to last a bit longer than some others. But praising a favorite is not the purpose of this thread. What we should be doing here is trashing the trashy ones. I am inviting griping. Come on you whiney bugs let us feel your disappointment!

Ah there are bay rum colognes, at least one that I know of. C.O. Bigelow makes a nice bay rum aftershave balm and cologne, available at bath & body works I think is where I got mine. The scent lasts a pretty long time and I enjoy the scent, it's a spicy bay rum scent ... and if you get the cologne you can use that as well with it and smell like the stuff longer. I have yet to use the cologne though I have it. Not as cheap as the other stuff though, the aftershave is about $20 and cologne $40.

It seems from most of the women that I've heard chime in somewhere on bay rum the consensus is they generally don't like it .. not sure how well that would hold up though as I've only heard opinions of a few. I know bay rum is probably my favorite scent of soap/cream/aftershave so far and it seems a lot of other guys also like it.

Edit: Available here as well, looks like they also have a body wash for the real bay rum enthusiast.

I'm thinking the same as "Icedog" It all comes from the same horse. The horse is fed different crap for a particular brand,, different bottles and slap on a lable. wala...... Of course, that's just MHO, pppfffffftttttttttttt

LIMIT

icedog feel free to send me your leftovers and I will gladly dispose of them for you.

Originally Posted by Doc

icedog feel free to send me your leftovers and I will gladly dispose of them for you.

Funny you should say that. The worst thing possible just happened last night. My girlfriend found that she likes the ones I don't like and wants to use them! Luckily the smell doesn't last.

Originally Posted by JMS

I use Dominica with and without lime exclusively And I must say that it is the purdyist smellin' horse piss this side of the Mississippi!

Hmm, I like the Capt Smith but maybe I'll have to try the Dominica. Just noticed you are almost my neighbor, I am in Oceanside and go to Ramona on occasion to chase some cows with my horse.

Mike

I want to chime in here .... I LOVE Bay Rum, I have a decent collection of them now. Among my everyday rotation I have Ogalalla,
Dominica, Captain Smith, and a bottle I got from a place call the
Old Village Barber Shop (I think they are in N.H.). The O.V.B.S has a Bay Rum deodorant that i LOVE!!!

But back to the subject at hand...

I think that the brand "Masters" Bay Rum is the most VILE smell I have ever tried ... I think it is from the same stream as the products you have described.

I know Masters has a following... but I don't understand why.

Just my 2 cents.....

Steve

Keep in mind when you go into one of those fru-fru expensive botiques and buy some imported or other after shave or cologne for the big bucks the stuff is made of alcohol, water and fragrance just like the cheap stuff just that it smells better to some.

By the way I think Dominica bay Rum smells great and anyone who dares knock old spice deserves to be executed.

I love Bay Rum. I like the post that there are crisp Island versions and clovey versions = I hadn't been able to articulate that in my own mind. Of those I've tried

1. Domenica - love it. [island]
2. Pinaud - love it. [island]
3. Ogallalah - love the old clovey version, new spicier version is ok, I have mixed feelings about the BR/Sandlewood and BR/LemonPeppercor
4. HoneyBeeGardens [clovey] - love it - it's slid under the radar

Old Spice Rocks.

Originally Posted by loueedacat

I love Bay Rum. I like the post that there are crisp Island versions and clovey versions = I hadn't been able to articulate that in my own mind. Of those I've tried

1. Domenica - love it. [island]
2. Pinaud - love it. [island]
3. Ogallalah - love the old clovey version, new spicier version is ok, I have mixed feelings about the BR/Sandlewood and BR/LemonPeppercor
4. HoneyBeeGardens [clovey] - love it - it's slid under the radar

Old Spice Rocks.

Hey great but this isn't about what bay rums you love. This thread is about the bay rums that suck, like Master's or the Dominica with lime.