I love three of the Pinaud scents - Original Clubman, the Special Reserve, and the Musk. Didn't care for the Bay Rum, and tossed it. I really like the Special Reserve!

My wife, OTOH, really DISlikes the Pinaud scents, and took me shopping for a scent she can live with! We both used to absolutely love "Kouros", by Yves St Laurent, but can't seem to find it anymore. So, she (we) settled on a new men's offering from Clinique for Men, called "Happy" for Men, oddly enough! Reminds me enough of the Kouros, and came with both a skin moisturizing aftershave cream, and the spray cologne/aftershave in the same scent.

I use the Clinique Happy when I am out or with her, and the Pinaud scents when I got to work, or it's just me out and about.