Thread: Looking for new aftershave recommendations

Alt Innsbruck- great menthol
Dr Harris sandalwood- last long
Osage rub- most menthol scent wears off

First three that come to mind that remind me of AV in feel. Then of course there is always Pinaud

I've tried various ones, including good ol' AV, thanks to suggestions from SRP posts. Below are some good ones that I like:
* Old Spice, Classic
* Old Spice, True Sport
* Pinaud, Clubman Original
* Pinaud, Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum
* Pinaud, Lilac Vegetal

Thanks for all the great feedback guys. Keep em comin.

I'm not ready to recommend any of these because they are newly added to my collection. I've just picked up DR Harris Sandalwood. It seems strong so I'll have to see if I can make a go of it. But it does seem like a great one. The other one I picked up today was Captains Choice Cat O Nine Tails Bay Rum. Imagine their traditional bay rum with a strong shot of licorice and molasses. After a few minutes it seems to settle down to a traditional bay rum. Last was something that I got a quick sample of in the store but had to order online since it was out of stock - Portland General Store, Whiskey Aftershave. It's a splash but not an alcohol splash. The scent seemed really good and seemed to continue to evolve over an hour or so on the back of my hand. All three seem like winners. I've used DR Harris products and Captains in the past. I trust they will be quality items. The wild card is the PGS product. I'm intrigued.

+1 for Captain's Choice Bay Rum. It's my favourite so far.

Picked up some clubman today. Still looking for something for weekend nights. Maybe something along the lines of St. Charles Shave.

Originally Posted by maddafinga

Have you tried bay rum or Osage rub?

+1 for Osage rub if you like the burn!

Dominica Bay Rum.

C&S 88 is awesome!!

Have fun.

Originally Posted by Lynn

C&S 88 is awesome!!

Have fun.

Yepp, that is great stuff indeed!