kwlfca:
It is difficult to recommend one aftershave balm, since your taste and mine are probably different, and that the fragrance I like you might not. I'll give you a selection of my preferred aftershave balms and leave you to choose.
Castle Forbes
Penhaligon's Blenheim Bouquet
Intitute Karite
Woods of Windsor — this has notes of bergamot and orange
Trumper's Coral Skin food
Xpec original
Edwin Jagger
That's all that comes to mind at this moment. Give them a try and see what you think.