Thread: The greatest misperception...

Originally Posted by UKRob

Although I wouldn't argue that 5/8" was the most widely sold size - there must be a reason why some of the Sheffield Manufacturers seemed to specialise in the larger blades. I don't recall seeing many 5/8" W&B for example whereas you see lots in the 7/8" and bigger varieties.

Originally Posted by Martin103

When looking at the evolution of the straight razor as far as we can go with correct provenance of dating a razor with a maker, you find that razor started in the 5/8 region, and wedge grind. With the advent of hollowing it seems like the razor are available in bigger sizes.

Like Edgewitt mentioned a Barber honing a razor frequently would want a larger size razor that will last longer, sounds like a plausible theory to me anyways. Going further with the more precise hollowing, to match the heft you need more length.
That said i dont have a preference in size or grind, its the beauty of the hobby to try different razors.

In another thread on this topic from sometime back, someone postulated that the nineteenth century Sheffield makers found a large razor more attractive to barbers, and others, because they held more lather when making passes. Requiring less rinsing/wiping, meaning completing shaves more quickly, and lasted longer overall, despite wear from honing. This also sounds plausible, though certainly not definitive.

I think one reason many of us have a fascination with the 'meat choppers' of Sheffield is the nostalgia factor, and they are just cool looking razors. Nice to use too.

I've got a big one and I love using it just feels so right in hand.

Originally Posted by celticcrusader

I've got a big one and I love using it just feels so right in hand.

Ah, another married guy, eh.

Bob

Originally Posted by BobH

Ah, another married guy, eh.

Bob

..................

Now. Why on Earth would a big razor appeal to anyone?

Overcompensation.

Originally Posted by Utopian

Overcompensation.

I knew you would be back around, Ron!

Originally Posted by sharptonn

I knew you would be back around, Ron!

I was waiting for that one to land.....

I had a friend who used to refer to all spoilers on the backs of cars as ***** extensions. Every time I see a spoiler, I still think the same thing.

Originally Posted by Phrank

I was waiting for that one to land.....

Where's Cheetahmeat when you need him?