Thread: Which (puck-style) soap should I try next?

Originally Posted by Nightblade

Yes ......Super Righteous Dudes ! Actually Straight razor designs. Lynn Abrams our Founder's company and SRP of course stands for Super righteous people or .....well......you get it anyway.

First bacon sandwiches and now super righteous dudes, is someone in a bit of a joking mood?

I vote for #1 Mitchells Wool Fat, #2 Tabac, #3 Straight Razor Designs. Tabac is the easiest soap, for me, to lather, followed by SRD's, then MWF. Once you get MWF dialed in, it is awesome. Good luck on your quest.

Bob, Slatterroy sounds good as I I like bayrum. Neroli, I'm not sure I've encountered that one yet, citrus sounds good though. The only one i wasn't sure about was the pine tar, hope they send some free samples...

While you got a long list and a good list already I think your missing pre de Provence. Nice subtle sage scent and great lather. Face feels great after using it.

Chris

Never had a bayrum soap but it does smell warm and spicy so I guess that is it and it is pleasant. Neither are over bearing in the scent department and lather easily. Yea, I was a little leery of the pine tar too. I think you will likely get a free sample too.

Bob

Originally Posted by Trimmy72

You know everytime one of these "recommend a shave soap or cream" post come up I need to learn to stay away..................bought some Fitjar at 3am this morning - working night shift & reading this thread = a purchase must be made

Same here. Bought 2 pucks of stirling soap last night because I read this thread... You all are a bad influence...

OTOH, I just got two exceptionally reasonable priced pucks of soap to try.

Originally Posted by Ludvig

First bacon sandwiches and now super righteous dudes, is someone in a bit of a joking mood?

It helps keep me young. Besides........whats not righteous about a dude with a super bacon sandwich ......right ?

Originally Posted by Nightblade

It helps keep me young. Besides........whats not righteous about a dude with a super bacon sandwich ......right ?

I guess you are right about that

Based on the wonderful recommendations from all of you, I have decided to try these (you know I couldn't stop at one!) —

Cella
Tabac
Mitchell's Wool Fat
Stirling
D. R. Harris

I would have also gone for Mike's Natural, but they were out of stock of the unscented one I wanted to try.

All those soaps are fine products that won't disappoint. Enjoy!