I prefer face lathering, mostly because I feel it makes it easier for me to judge when I've reached the right water content (i.e. when I'm getting to the right slickness). But I still use a scuttle as well. I just sold my big scuttle and got a small one. After face lathering I leave the brush in the scuttle and it stays nice and warm for passes 2 and 3. I know, winter is here and I'm a wimp :-)