Results 1 to 10 of 172
Thread: Science vs Pseudoscience
Threaded View
-
11-02-2009, 05:31 PM #29
By your definition of science, it sounds like a double blind taste test to determine which of two types of chocolate tastes better would be scientific. While the process may be scientific, I don't think the results are. Or I could compare the temperatures of two beakers of water by smelling them. I'm comparing them, I know the variables, and the test is unbiased. Is that science?
Why is science watertight? What about the process makes it so? How many scientific papers do you read that are clear and concise?
To say that science has a scientific process is quite circular. What are the criteria for a process to be scientific. For all you've said, though there is a start in your first section, there is very little definition. You've said what science is as the result of it following a "scientific process" - watertight, backed up, evidence based - but nothing about what defines something as scientific.
Like Einstein and all other theoretical physicists?
Black holes - when the volume decreases, objects are able to get much, much closer to the black hole, and that is where gravity increases dramatically. Yes, if you are 10 light years away there is no difference, but when you are just outside the event horizon there is a huge difference.
Big Bang Theory - while the theory may be largely incomplete, that does not make it non-scientific. The structure of the universe, cosmic background radiation, the expansion of the universe, and a number of other carefully documented phenomena can be explained through a theory such as the big bang theory. Is the theory correct? Maybe. Is it a scientific theory? Yes.
Black holes have been created in labs, and they are created in our atmosphere all the time as well. The black holes that I am speaking of fit the only important definition of a black hole, which is the ratio of mass to radius - namely the Schwarzchild radius.
In what way is the big bang theory geocentric?
I'm sure there are scientists who are out there trying to prove the big bang theory, but there are lots of others seeking out alternate explanations.