Thread: Naniwa 12K after a Coticule, to improve edges that are good but not great?

Originally Posted by Jimbo7

I don’t get this! We’re not here to find one solution--it’s been mentioned in this very forum that there isn’t one solution! So then what’s the harm in providing additional solutions!?

You just answered your own question...

There is not one solution if there was then this would be a rather boring place... Anytime everyone agrees then there is no progress, if we all agreed on only one way to do things, then we would just have a mutual backslapping fourm...
I like the arguments myself they foster new ideas, it doesn't even matter if those ideas are hatched because you are bound and determined to prove somebody else wrong, it might make you go test it out...

The big argument going on now, is that Paul doesn't think that certain stones produce better edges on certain razors, and I do...
So the solution is to try it and see what you find, the problem is that it costs huge money and time to do the testing..

Lee/Hoglahoo just summed up the Original question of the thread rather easily