Thread: Are there any more good tallow triple-milled soaps - besides DRH, MWF, Tabac and C&S?

Originally Posted by PLANofMAN

And Cyril R. Salter.

I found these amongst others at Top of the Chain - https://topofthechain.ca/

Tallow based, but not necessarily triple milled:

MOON SOAPS | OLD SCHOOL TALLOW SHAVE SOAP
CHISELED FACE GHOST TOWN BARBER – SILK TALLOW SHAVE SOAP
MACDUFFS SOAP COMPANY | TRAIL TOBACCO SHAVE SOAP

Originally Posted by DZEC

I found these amongst others at Top of the Chain - https://topofthechain.ca/

Tallow based, but not necessarily triple milled:

MOON SOAPS | OLD SCHOOL TALLOW SHAVE SOAP
CHISELED FACE GHOST TOWN BARBER – SILK TALLOW SHAVE SOAP
MACDUFFS SOAP COMPANY | TRAIL TOBACCO SHAVE SOAP

Pre De Provence 63

Cyril R. Salter makes a great hard soap.

Originally Posted by DZEC

Tallow based, but not necessarily triple milled

Originally Posted by STF

Pre De Provence 63

There is indeed a huge variety of tallow based artisanal shaving soaps that are not triple-milled. During the last decade I have tried some three dozens of them, and still have about a dozen in my current rotation. However I have to say that none of them was to my personal liking as much as any of the triple-milled classics. A matter of personal preference I guess - hence this particular thread

Originally Posted by PLANofMAN

And Cyril R. Salter.

Originally Posted by Pedigree

Cyril R. Salter makes a great hard soap.

I always believed Salter's soap was almost identical to DRH's lavender, so I guessed DRH were manufacturing it for Salter. Now that I think of it, it can't be right: probably some third party manufactures for both companies with similar list of ingredients and olfactory additives. Which means the list of tallow-based triple-milled soaps should indeed include them as separate entities: D.R.Harris, Cyril R. Salter, and Henri et Victoria.

Originally Posted by dimab

There is indeed a huge variety of tallow based artisanal shaving soaps that are not triple-milled. During the last decade I have tried some three dozens of them, and still have about a dozen in my current rotation. However I have to say that none of them was to my personal liking as much as any of the triple-milled classics. A matter of personal preference I guess - hence this particular thread





I always believed Salter's soap was almost identical to DRH's lavender, so I guessed DRH were manufacturing it for Salter. Now that I think of it, it can't be right: probably some third party manufactures for both companies with similar list of ingredients and olfactory additives. Which means the list of tallow-based triple-milled soaps should indeed include them as separate entities: D.R.Harris, Cyril R. Salter, and Henri et Victoria.

D.R. Harris and Cyril R. Salter are both made by Culmak. I don't know who makes Henri et Victoria. I always assumed it was an Artisan soap, made in house.